Faithful judge, faithful shepherd
Facing mortal danger, David cries out to his good Shepherd, asking him to protect him from evildoers and then gratefully rejoices in the assurance that he will do so.
A David psalm.
1 I cry out to you
YHWH, my rock.
Don’t be deaf to me!
Because if you stay silent on me
I’ll be like those dropped into open graves.
2 Listen to the sound of my pleading
as I cry to you for help
lifting up my hands
toward your holy sanctuary.
3 Don’t drag me off with the wicked
practitioners of evil
who speak peace to their neighbors
while evil is in their hearts.
4 Pay them back for all they’ve done—
give them everything their evil deserves.
Pay them for every evil deed—
wound for wound and grief for grief.
5 Because they pay no attention
to any of YHWH’s work—
any of the things he’s done—
he will tear them down
never to rebuild them.
6 Blessed be YHWH
because he’s heard my plea for help!
7 YHWH is my strength
and the shield my heart trusts in.
Because he’s helped me
my heart is full of joy
and overflows with songs of praise.
8 YHWH is the strength of his people
the fortress that saves his anointed.
9 Rescue your people
and bless your inheritance.
Be their good shepherd
and carry them in your arms forever.

Like Psalm 27, this is a psalm of contrasting moods, but David reverses the order here, putting his plea first, his praise last. Though his life is in danger, he’s received no response to any of his urgent pleas directed toward God’s sanctuary. He fears God may have mixed him up with those who deserve to die. Verses 4-5 contrast the wicked person’s work with God’s work—respectively, doing evil and doing good. God’s work includes things like giving sunshine and rain, redeeming and blessing his people, and punishing evil.
Some Christians blanch when the psalmist asks God to judge evildoers, as if we should just forgive and forget their evil. But that’s not how a moral universe works. God will yet judge those who viciously attack the innocent, and we needn’t apologize for asking him to do so.
Here we must distinguish between personal and absolute forgiveness. God alone forgives the guilty absolutely, though that may not exempt them from temporal punishment. When we forgive, however—as Dietrich Bonhoeffer forgave the Nazis who oppressed him—this doesn’t mean we should pray the evildoer will escape punishment. The same Bonhoeffer who forgave the Nazis personally was right to pray that God would faithfully judge them for all their evils, as God eventually did.
Verse 5 is pivotal: knowing God will ring down the curtain on evildoers, David realizes he’s been heard—YHWH will spare his life after all! So, his confidence spills out in joyful praise. In the ancient Middle East, the image of shepherd was always kingly, though not typically kindly, as here. David concludes by commending his deliverer to all his people and asking God to carry them in his arms whenever their strength fails.
Prayer:
Many today live without regard for you or your laws, God. Thank you that you hold evildoers to account. Please bring evil’s reign of terror to its swift and timely end. Thank you that you also shelter and shepherd your people. Help me to trust you to bless and care for me always. Amen.
In your free moments today, pray these words:
Rescue your chosen people
and bless your inheritance.
Be their good shepherd
and carry them in your arms forever.